Welcome to the home of the “Sweetie Pie”

Ever just want to change it up? Do you like that sauce that’s a little different? Try our sweetie pie. Our special recipe for a sweet sauce that will have you telling your friends and coming back for more. There’s a reason our sweetie pie has been voted best pizza 5 years running! Come try for yourself. 

About us order now

Did a take out order, while we waited for our pizza nearly every staff member took the time to chat with my little one, which delights him and helps me. He was able to watch them make a pizza and the man who was making the pizza talked to him the entire time! Such nice, friendly people who went above and beyond for us!! We loved our Sweetie Pie!! 


Main St. Pizza of Eagleville makes the best Pizza…
Sweetie Pie is my absolute favorite. We order weekly. Our kids are always asking for Main St. 
Even when we were at the Jersey Shore last summer, they didn’t want the local pizza shop, they only wanted Main St. FIVE STARS ALL THE WAY !!!

Anne / Facebook

I must say I have been trying for a long time to get to this fabulous place and I finally did tonight, it was the best pizza we have had and believe me when I tell you we have tried them all, my husbands favorite food so we call him the pizza “connoisseur ” he said lets go tomorrow!! The wings were my sons all time favorite, we can’t wait to go back and try the rest, love this place and the people who own it!!

Pennie / Facebook

Latest news

Please note: We stop taking delivery orders a half hour prior to close. Pick up orders can still be placed. Thanks.


3140 West Ridge Pike

Eagleville, Pa 19403

Get Directions



Email Us


Follow Us on Social Media


Monday 10:30am-8pm

Tuesday 10:30am-8:30pm

Wednesday 10:30am-8:30pm

Thursday 10:30am-8:30pm

Friday 10:30am-9pm

Saturday 10:30am-8:30pm

Sunday 10:30am-8:30pm

Carfagno's Main Street Pizzeria & Grille